MoinMoin Vs Distributed Wiki

Loading

A comparison of MoinMoin and the Distributed Wiki



Vs
Distributed Wiki MoinMoin

 

MoinMoin and Distributed Wiki appear to be very similar.  Both are written in Python, provide a hierarchy of wiki pages, page versions, and are customizable.  But they are conceptually very different and they target different markets.

Maybe the largest difference is the target market.  MoinMoin is targeted at corporate Python developers.  You have to be comfortable with command line development in Python. The Distributed Wiki is much more broadly accessible.    Anyone with a web browser can use it.  You can start using it as is, or you can modify the HTML, CSS and Javascript, in the browser.  With MoinMoin you have to be able to work on the file system to even get it running.  So the Distributed Wiki has a much much much larger population which can use it.  It could even be in the Windows App Store. 

They are also very different conceptually.  At its core, MoinMoin is a list of wiki pages.  Because page names can share substrings, it supports simple hierarchies.  In contrast, the Distributed Wiki is a tree of content types, a first cousin to Plone.  Not just a CMS, but a complete web development environment. 

The difference is very clear when dealing with larger hierarchies.  Here is a tree of over a 1000 items, built using the DIstributed Wiki.  A basic principal in human factors is that no category should contain more than about 7 items.  So the Distributed Wiki has very deep, but easy to understand hierarchies.  In contrast MoinMoin handles this list of 486 items mostly as a list.  There is a little bit of hierarchy in the list.   I tried reading through it, but it really is way way too much for the human brain to make sense of.  Rather than being sorted alphabetically it should be a deeper tree of categories. 

MoinMoin has very few content types.  Maybe a wiki page, and a file or image.  Content types are very powerful.  For example the Distributed Wiki has a Google Maps content type.  Here is an example of hierarchical maps running on an older version of the software. 

Being browser editable is very powerful. There was a recent MoinMoin discussion about being able to modify favicon.ico.  They had to make some changes to make it possible for developers to git clone the repository, edit the Python, and change the favicon.  In the Distributed Wiki, an end user just use the Web GUI to delete and upload a new favicon.  Much easier.  A lot more people can do that. 

The two products are  at different stages in the life cycles.  MoinMoin is old mature software.  The above list of feature requests shows how it may evolve in the future. The distributed wiki has just been released.  It is not "just a wiki".  It is a complete web development environment.  We have no idea what new content types, and distributed content types will be released.   


Parent Web Pages

1. Forest Chat Wiki
2. Other Other Interesting Wiki Pages
3. MoinMoin Vs Distributed Wiki A comparison of MoinMoin and the Distributed Wiki